Personal commentary · Opinion & Analysis
The Human Cost of America's Immigration Enforcement
ICE, a $113 Billion Funding Expansion, and the Question of National Priorities
By Vitalii Lunko ·
The immigration debate in the United States is often reduced to a simple choice between border security and open borders. That framing leaves out the most important questions: How much power should immigration-enforcement agencies possess? What safeguards should protect a person from an irreversible mistake? And what does it say about national priorities when detention and deportation receive extraordinary new funding while health coverage for vulnerable Americans faces major reductions?
A country has the right to establish immigration rules and enforce them. But the existence of that right does not settle whether a particular enforcement system is humane, effective, proportionate, or accountable. Those questions deserve a serious examination—not only in Congress, but in every community affected by immigration policy.
1. More Than $113 Billion for ICE: Understanding the Numbers
The scale of the recent funding expansion is extraordinary. In July 2025, Congress provided U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) with approximately $74.85 billion in multiyear funding, including $45 billion for detention capacity. In June 2026, another law allocated approximately $38.53 billion to ICE, including funding for Homeland Security Investigations and immigration enforcement operations. Together, the two laws provided approximately $113.38 billion in additional funding, available over multiple years, generally through fiscal year 2029. These figures are separate from the agency's ordinary annual funding arrangements. [1]
This is an important distinction: ICE does not have a $113 billion annual operating budget. The figure represents major additional appropriations spread across several years. Yet that qualification does not make the policy choice insignificant. More detention facilities, additional personnel, larger removal operations, and more extensive enforcement infrastructure are being financed on a historic scale.
Money does not merely support existing government priorities. It changes what a government becomes capable of doing. Once an enormous detention and removal infrastructure has been built, the pressure to use it can become a political and institutional force of its own.
2. Detention Expands While Healthcare Faces Cuts
The debate becomes even more consequential when immigration funding is compared with changes to healthcare programs.
The Congressional Budget Office estimated that the 2025 reconciliation law would reduce projected federal Medicaid spending by approximately $989.7 billion over ten years, compared with the previous baseline. Its Medicaid provisions were also projected to increase the number of uninsured people by 7.5 million in 2034. Those are forward-looking estimates, not a claim that all those people have already lost coverage. [2]
Medicaid and Medicare are different programs. Medicaid provides coverage for many low-income adults, children, people with disabilities, and people needing long-term care. Medicare primarily covers older Americans and certain people with disabilities. The direct Medicare provisions of the same 2025 law were projected to produce a small net increase in spending, rather than the large cut associated with Medicaid. [2]
The funding figures also cover different time periods and should not be treated as a one-for-one accounting trade. Nevertheless, the contrast raises a legitimate question of priorities. Why is such vast new capacity being devoted to detention and removal at a time when lawmakers are reducing projected support for healthcare coverage?
A society's priorities can be measured in part by what it is willing to finance. It is reasonable to ask whether some of the energy devoted to expanding enforcement should instead be focused on the ability of struggling families, children, older adults, and people with disabilities to obtain care.
3. What Happens Inside Detention Centers?
The expansion is not just a line in the federal budget. It has changed the scale of immigration detention. According to a September 2026 Government Accountability Office report, ICE's average daily detention population rose from approximately 39,300 in January 2025 to 67,200 by July 2026. The number of authorized detention facilities roughly doubled during that period. [3]
Oversight findings have raised concerns about whether this growth has been planned or monitored adequately. In September 2026, the GAO reported that ICE had purchased eleven warehouses for roughly $1 billion to convert into detention facilities and then planned to sell seven. More than $20 million in associated costs could not be recovered. Another GAO report found performance and safety problems at the large Camp East Montana detention facility. [3][4]
The human consequences deserve equal attention. A March 2026 analysis by the health-policy organization KFF reported 46 deaths in ICE custody or detention facilities from January 2025 through March 18, 2026, based on ICE reporting. California's attorney general also documented overcrowding and shortcomings in medical care at seven detention facilities inspected in that state. These findings do not establish that every facility has the same problems, but they demonstrate that concerns about detention conditions are not merely political rhetoric. [5][6]
Immigration detention is generally a civil system rather than a sentence imposed after a criminal conviction. That distinction should heighten the need for safeguards. Being detained while immigration proceedings continue should not mean being denied dignity, medical attention, access to evidence, or a meaningful opportunity to be heard.
4. A Ukrainian Friend's Story: From a Rideshare Delivery to a War Zone
Behind national statistics are individual lives. One experience, shared by someone personally known to the author, illustrates why the consequences of immigration enforcement cannot be understood through budget figures alone.
The man was Ukrainian and had entered the United States through a humanitarian parole arrangement connected with the war in Ukraine. Humanitarian parole can provide temporary lawful permission to enter and remain in the country, but it is not permanent immigration status, and authorization can expire. The exact status of his parole at the time of his detention has not been independently established for this article.
He was earning a living by driving for Uber and Lyft. According to the account, he agreed to transport a sealed package without the sender accompanying it. Accepting an unaccompanied parcel was a serious lapse in judgment. But making a poor decision is not the same thing as knowingly participating in a crime.
He reportedly had extensive camera recordings—covering the inside and outside of the vehicle—and provided information about his route and the location where the package was dropped off, near a McDonald's in Georgia. According to the account, these recordings and delivery details were offered to explain his role and his lack of knowledge about the parcel's contents.
What happened afterward was devastating. He was detained, held in conditions described as extremely difficult, and eventually deported to Ukraine in handcuffs. The account states that after his return he was sent to the front line of the war. The United States did not itself assign him to military service; the concern is that removal returned him to a country where he subsequently faced that danger.
The underlying documents have not been independently reviewed. It is therefore not possible to determine from this account what criminal or immigration charges, if any, were formally brought; what evidence officials relied upon; what proceedings occurred; or what opportunity he had to challenge removal. His friend describes the process as one in which meaningful defense was unavailable. Those unresolved questions are precisely why transparent procedures matter.
Even when a person's immigration status provides a lawful ground for removal, the legal ability to deport someone and the moral wisdom of doing so are not always identical. A decision that may look routine in an administrative file can become life-altering when the destination is a country at war.
This case raises a fundamental question: Were the person's circumstances, available evidence, and foreseeable risks examined with the care that such an irreversible decision required?
5. Does the Crime Data Support Broad Suspicion of Immigrants?
Much of the political justification for aggressive immigration enforcement is presented in the language of public safety. Serious crime should be investigated, and people who commit violent offenses should be held accountable. But claims that immigrants as a group are more dangerous than people born in the United States do not match several major research findings.
A March 2026 analysis by the Cato Institute, using estimates based on 2024 Census data, reported incarceration rates per 100,000 people of approximately 303 for legal immigrants, 674 for undocumented immigrants, and 1,195 for native-born Americans. These figures describe incarceration, not every criminal offense committed, and the classifications depend on the study's methods. They nevertheless challenge the assumption that undocumented immigrants are more likely to be incarcerated than native-born residents. [7]
A peer-reviewed study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, using Texas data from 2012 through 2018, also found lower felony arrest rates among undocumented immigrants than among native-born citizens. In that state and period, U.S.-born citizens were more than twice as likely to be arrested for violent crimes, about 2.5 times as likely for drug crimes, and more than four times as likely for property crimes. Texas data cannot automatically be treated as current national crime rates, but they provide an important independent point of comparison. [8]
None of this means immigrants never commit crimes. Individuals must be judged by their actions, not by an idealized picture of any group. It does mean that nationality or immigration status alone is a poor substitute for evidence of criminal behavior.
A person trying to work, pay rent, support a family, and avoid deportation is not automatically a public-safety threat. Treating an entire category of residents as suspects imposes costs on people who have done nothing to justify that suspicion.
6. The Economic Consequences Reach American Workers, Too
The economic effects of aggressive enforcement do not stop with the people arrested or removed. Immigrant workers participate in construction, agriculture, hospitality, transportation, healthcare support, and small businesses. Their labor, spending, and entrepreneurship affect customers and coworkers throughout the economy.
A September 2026 Brookings study estimated that in 64 cities experiencing the largest increases in ICE enforcement, employment was 0.43% below its expected path six months after the surge. The authors found the shortfall exceeded the number of direct arrests and estimated that some of the affected jobs would have been held by U.S.-born workers. These are research estimates, with the usual limitations of observational economic analysis, rather than a count of every job directly lost because of ICE. [9]
Immigration has genuine economic tradeoffs, including pressures on housing in some places. Acknowledging those tradeoffs is compatible with recognizing that sudden, sweeping enforcement can disrupt businesses and neighborhoods far beyond those directly targeted.
For a small contractor, losing workers can delay projects. For a restaurant, uncertainty can mean shorter hours or fewer customers. For a family, detention can mean the disappearance of a paycheck overnight. Fear itself can have economic effects when people stop commuting, shopping, working, or seeking services.
The American dream has long included the possibility that someone can arrive with little, work hard, and build a better life. That aspiration has not disappeared, but enforcement practices can make it harder for many families to pursue it.
7. Due Process Should Not Depend on Citizenship
The rule of law requires more than the government's authority to enforce rules. It also requires meaningful checks on mistakes and abuses of power.
In ordinary proceedings before an immigration judge, people have the right to seek representation at their own expense or through free legal services, present evidence, and challenge evidence against them. The government generally does not provide a free lawyer in these civil proceedings. Procedures also differ for expedited removal and other immigration processes. [10]
That legal framework makes access to competent advice, interpreters, case records, and timely review especially important. A person who does not understand the process, cannot obtain legal assistance, or cannot present relevant recordings may struggle to make a meaningful defense even when formal rights exist on paper.
The friend’s story does not establish a legal due-process violation without a review of his records. But it shows why the question cannot be dismissed. If the government is going to make decisions with consequences as grave as detention and removal to an active war zone, the standards for accuracy and review must be correspondingly serious.
8. Reform, Replacement, or Abolition?
Supporters of ICE argue that the agency enforces federal law, removes people subject to deportation, and investigates serious offenses, including trafficking and exploitation. Those are legitimate government functions, and public safety cannot simply be ignored. ICE also contains separate branches: its Enforcement and Removal Operations division handles much of detention and deportation, while Homeland Security Investigations conducts criminal investigations. [11]
The position advanced in this essay goes beyond a smaller budget or marginal reforms. It calls for permanently ending ICE as it is currently organized, rather than continuing to expand the same institution and expecting modest policy changes to eliminate its failures.
That position does not require abandoning immigration law or refusing to investigate serious crimes. Essential criminal-investigation functions would still have to be assigned to accountable agencies, while immigration cases would require a fair and workable administrative system. Any transition would need detailed legislation, clear responsibility for public safety, and independent oversight.
Abolition is a substantial institutional proposal, not a simple budget adjustment. Its supporters should be prepared to explain how legitimate functions would continue. Its critics should, in turn, explain why an agency whose expansion has produced documented management failures and serious detention concerns should remain structured as it is.
The Measure of a Country
Immigration laws matter. So do borders, security, and public confidence. But those interests do not erase individual humanity, nor do they make every expansion of detention power wise or necessary.
The questions are concrete. Are people being treated as individuals, with their evidence and circumstances considered? Are detention facilities safe and properly supervised? Does the scale of enforcement reflect actual public-safety needs? Are the economic consequences being measured? And can the government defend its budget choices when so many residents struggle to obtain essential healthcare?
A particularly difficult test is the case of someone who came from a country at war, tried to earn a living in America, and was returned to that war under circumstances that remain contested. The story deserves careful verification. It also deserves more than indifference.
A country's strength is measured not only by the power it possesses to enforce its laws, but by the care it takes when exercising that power over another human life.
Sources and further reading
- [1] Congressional Research Service, Department of Homeland Security Appropriations: FY2026 State of Play (June 24, 2026).
- [2] Congressional Research Service, Health Provisions in P.L. 119-21 (Aug. 18, 2025).
- [3] Government Accountability Office, Immigration Detention: Urgent Planning Needed to Avoid Further Waste of Taxpayer Dollars (Sept. 24, 2026).
- [4] Government Accountability Office, Waste and Performance Issues at Camp East Montana (June 9, 2026).
- [5] KFF, Deaths and Health Care Issues in ICE Detention Centers Under the Second Trump Administration (Mar. 25, 2026).
- [6] California Department of Justice, Fifth Report on Conditions at Immigration Detention Facilities in California (May 15, 2026).
- [7] Cato Institute, The Immigrant Crime Narrative Doesn't Match the Data (Mar. 25, 2026).
- [8] Light, He & Robey, Comparing crime rates between undocumented immigrants, legal immigrants, and native-born US citizens in Texas, PNAS (2020).
- [9] Brookings Institution, Beyond arrests: How ICE enforcement depressed local employment in 2025 (Sept. 4, 2026).
- [10] U.S. Department of Justice, EOIR, Learn About the Immigration Court.
- [11] Congressional Research Service, Immigration Legislation and Issues in the 119th Congress (July 14, 2026).
Editorial note: The personal account is based on information supplied by the author. No immigration records, criminal case documents, detention records, or Ukrainian military records were made available for independent verification. Identifying information has been withheld.
